★ FROM OUR SPONSOR

58% of shoppers now ask AI tools what to buy instead of searching, and about 85% of what those tools say about a brand comes from other people: reviews, best-of lists, videos and creator posts. When a shopper asks ChatGPT for the best gift this Black Friday, the answer is built from what creators say about you.

That makes BFCM the week your creator program matters most, and the week most programs break: briefs land late, codes leak to coupon sites, and gifts never turn into posts.

UpPromote, the data-backed affiliate platform built for Shopify, pulled 13 recipes from 65+ brands including Click & Grow, cfab and Vetain, each with the real setup and results. Click & Grow grew BFCM affiliate revenue 272% in a year. Here's how.

What Amazon's Fees, Ad Lawsuit and Text Ads Mean for Sellers

Three things happened to Amazon sellers in roughly a week. Individually, each is a news item. Together, they look a lot like a pricing strategy.

On 29 October, Amazon's Q3 results showed that third-party seller services plus advertising hit $66.1 billion, which is 96.6% of the $68.5 billion it made selling its own stuff. A year ago, that ratio was 89.3%. On 5 November, the FTC and 22 state attorneys general unredacted chunks of their lawsuit alleging Amazon quietly marked up ad prices by up to 50% above auction results on ordinary days, and up to 250% on Prime Day and Black Friday. (Amazon disputes this. Firmly. More on that shortly.) And the very next day, Amazon started letting shoppers text Alexa for Shopping like it's a mate who happens to own a warehouse, with Sponsored Products tucked neatly into the replies.

They say timing is everything in comedy. Apparently also in quarterly reporting.

When the Toll Booth Nearly Out-Earns the Shop

Critics have called Amazon a toll road for years: a referral fee on every sale, a fulfilment fee for the warehouse, and ads for the privilege of being seen in a shop you're already paying rent in. What's new is the scale.

Seller services grew 9% to $46.5 billion. Advertising grew 11% to $19.6 billion. Amazon's own retail business grew a slightly sleepy 2%. Third-party sellers now account for 61% of paid units, so the people paying the tolls are also doing most of the driving.

To be fair to the maths (someone has to be), Prime Day moved from July to June this year, which flatters the comparison. But even combining Q2 and Q3, the gap between Amazon's retail sales and what it collects from sellers halved year on year, from $12.7 billion to $6.2 billion. On current trends, the lines cross within a couple of years, although the holiday quarter, being retail's favourite child, will probably widen the gap first.

The crossover date matters less than the direction. Amazon still competes with us for the same sale, but we're also increasingly its customers, buying access to its shoppers, logistics and ad inventory. A business earning nearly as much from selling access as from selling products has a very healthy interest in making that access more necessary. The interesting question is how it prices it.

The Auction That (Allegedly) Had a Secret Ingredient

Which brings us to the FTC.

Amazon's sponsored ads run on what Amazon has described as a generalised second-price auction. Translation: you pay roughly what it takes to beat the next-highest bid, not your full bid. Pretty much every Amazon advertiser has built their bidding strategy on that assumption, the way you build a house on the assumption that the ground will stay where you left it.

The FTC alleges that from 2019, Amazon added an undisclosed surcharge, referred to internally as a "soft reserve price." (A phrase with the same calming energy as "minor service adjustment" on a broadband bill.) According to the complaint, advertisers routinely paid more than the competitive auction alone would have produced, with average cost per click rising around 20% in the 2021 holiday season and more than 200% for some advertisers.

But the size isn't the most uncomfortable bit. The timing is. Regulators allege Amazon raised its surcharge ceilings around its biggest events, reasoning that advertisers would blame seasonal competition. The complaint also says prices were ramped up gradually beforehand to make increases harder to spot, and that advertisers who asked directly got misleading answers.

If true, it's a remarkably clever plan, in the way that hiding vegetables in a toddler's pasta is clever. Except here the toddler is also paying for the pasta.

Amazon's position: no advertiser pays more than its bid, reserve prices are standard across the ad industry, and it will defend itself in court. Both points are fair. The real dispute is about disclosure: whether advertisers were told the auction worked one way while it worked another. Several figures remain redacted, the release doesn't say whether any of this continued past 2023, and these are allegations, not findings.

Still. Black Friday is 27 November. Every Amazon advertiser is about to stroll straight into the exact period the complaint describes as surcharge season. No pressure.

Your Ads Have Slid Into the DMs

Against that cheerful backdrop, Amazon has opened a new lane.

On 6 November, it launched text ordering for Alexa for Shopping, the agent that replaced Rufus earlier this year (RIP Rufus, we barely knew you). It's invite-only for a small group of US customers for now, with Amazon planning to expand to millions more in the coming weeks.

Customers link a phone number, get a new contact called "Alexa Shopping," and text it things like: reorder the usual, build a grocery list from this recipe photo, find a gift that arrives by Saturday. It searches, compares, suggests, and checks out once approved. There's also an auto-buy setting that pounces when a price drops to a level you've set. Basically CamelCamelCamel with a credit card and initiative.

Sponsored Products show up in the agent's shortlist. Auto-buys and reorders stay ad-free. And for now, the placements are free to advertisers.

Free. From the company currently being sued for allegedly overcharging for ads. I'm sure it's fine.

Amazon says more than 400 million customers used Alexa for Shopping in the past year, and agentic feature use is up more than eightfold since January. Both numbers are Amazon's own, but even with a generous haircut, this isn't a channel we get to ignore.

Three Slots, No Benchmark, One Very Motivated Landlord

A search results page can show dozens of products. A text message cannot, unless Amazon is planning a 4,000-word SMS (please nobody give them ideas). Ask for a science gift for a ten-year-old, under £30, arriving Saturday, and you'll get three or four suggestions, max.

That changes the economics in three ways.

Scarcity. Fewer slots means each one is worth more, to the seller who wins it and to Amazon once it attaches a price tag. The free period is essentially a pricing experiment: how much commercial content will shoppers tolerate in a personal message thread, and how well does it convert? Earlier Amazon ad formats went the same way: quietly, cheaply, then at scale. And if the FTC's allegations hold up, pricing in a format with far less competition is unlikely to be easier to check.

Measurement. Nobody can yet say what counts as an impression in a text thread, how a sponsored suggestion that leads to a purchase six messages later gets attributed, or whether that purchase would have happened anyway. With no established benchmark, advertisers will rely almost entirely on Amazon's own reporting. Which is, you'll notice, precisely the kind of reliance the FTC complaint is poking at.

The ad-free bits. The one brand owners should watch most closely. Auto-buy and reorder flows carry no ads, which sounds lovely for shoppers. It also means that once an agent has settled on a brand of laundry pods or dog food, a competitor has no paid way to interrupt. In repeat-purchase categories, the discovery slot may be a challenger's only shot. Incumbents get an advantage that never shows up in any ad budget. (Brand loyalty, but automated. Romantic, really.)

Before We All Grab the Pitchforks

It would be easy to read all this as pure extraction. There's a reasonable case against that.

First, seller fees and advertising have stayed at roughly a third of Amazon's total revenue since 2024, because AWS keeps growing even faster. Sellers are becoming more central to Amazon's retail economics, not to Amazon overall.

Second, Amazon is hardly alone. Walmart's ad business is growing faster than its sales. TikTok Shop sellers pay creators a cut of every sale. DTC brands pay Meta and Google for traffic. Even Reddit, watching search referrals shrink, started testing ads inside its own search results this month. Wherever shopping intent gathers, someone puts a turnstile in front of it. Leaving Amazon doesn't mean escaping the toll. It means paying a different one, usually with worse signage.

Which is why the most useful number isn't Amazon's take rate in isolation. It's contribution margin by channel: what's left after fees, ads and fulfilment, compared across everywhere you sell.

What We Can Actually Do Before Black Friday

Audit the history. If you've got several years of campaign data, compare actual cost per click against your max bids, especially around Prime Day, Black Friday and Cyber Monday in 2021, 2022 and 2023, the periods the complaint focuses on. It won't prove anything, but it will show whether your cost history matches the pattern regulators describe, which could matter if the case ever leads to a remedy.

Separate the problems. If efficiency drops during peak, work out whether clicks got pricier or fewer converted. The two look identical in a summary dashboard and need completely different fixes.

Write for the agent, not the keyword. In the conversational channel, the job is less about bidding and more about being selected. An agent texting back three options chooses on product data: whether your listing clearly answers constraints on price, delivery, age suitability, size and use. Listings written for keyword matching will get passed over, paid placement or not. And in repeat-purchase categories, win the first purchase, because the agent may handle every one after it without ever showing an ad.

The Bottom Line

Seller fees and advertising nearly match Amazon's own retail sales. A federal complaint alleges the auction we use to buy visibility was secretly surcharged, most heavily on the days that matter most. And the next lane of the toll road is a text thread with room for a handful of sponsored products, no agreed way to measure them and, for now, no price.

The open questions matter more than the answers. Will Amazon define impressions and attribution for conversational placements before it starts charging, or after? Will any FTC-driven transparency carry over to formats with three slots, or stop politely at the search results page? And as repeat purchases drift into ad-free agent flows, will challenger brands have to treat the first sale as a loss leader?

We'll find out from our own cost reports. So the sensible move right now is making sure we can actually read them.

Jo

P.S. If Alexa Shopping ever texts you "u up?" at midnight with a sponsored air fryer, that's not a bug. That's the roadmap.

P.P.S. I'm officially adopting "soft reserve price" for every unexplained line item on every invoice I've ever received. Starting, naturally, with Amazon's.

WANT TO REACH 70,000+ ECOMMERCE READERS?

Put your brand in front of an engaged audience of 70,000+ subscribers, with 75% based in the US.

Interested in sponsoring our newsletter? Get our media kit & rates.

The Quick Read:

The Tools List:

🤖 Kittl - Speed up your workflows with AI-powered design tools and gain instant access to a ton of stunning illustrations, fonts, photos, icons, and textures.

😎 Alta Daily - Your personal AI stylist that truly gets you

📆 Before Sunset - An AI personal assistant that plans your day by automatically generating daily schedules.

📹 Quso AI - Get social-ready clips, cut & captioned by AI.

ABOUT THE WRITER:

Meet Joanna (Jo) Lambadjieva

Jo Lambadjieva is an entrepreneur and AI expert in the e-commerce industry. She is the founder and CEO of Amazing Wave, an agency specializing in AI-driven solutions for e-commerce businesses. With over 13 years of experience in digital marketing, agency work, and e-commerce, Joanna has established herself as a thought leader in integrating AI technologies for business growth.

background