★ FROM OUR SPONSOR
Selling on Amazon and eyeing TikTok Shop? This free live workshop shows you how to get there through creators. Longtime Amazon seller and Spliced founder Leo Sgovio walks through 7 hacks and AI tactics sellers are using right now to grow across both marketplaces with creator communities and networks. He demos every strategy live.
If you register, you get an extended 2-week Spliced trial. You also get early access to the Black Friday deal before it goes public: 50% off annual or 30% off monthly for your first year. If you join live, Leo adds free Claude skills.
Today, Nov 20, 1 PM ET. Can’t make it?

ChatGPT Business Profiles: What They’ll Really Cost

As of 10 November, businesses can claim a profile inside ChatGPT, upload their product data and, in the US, have OpenAI build them a sales agent. Most people reached for the AOL comparison, and it's a good one, up to a point: it captures where OpenAI wants this to go. Where it's less helpful, I think, is on cost.
For anyone who missed the mid-1990s (congratulations on your knees), AOL was how millions first got online: dial-up, that screeching noise, and free installation CDs arriving through the letterbox with the persistence of a utility company. Once inside, you rarely left. Everything lived in a space AOL controlled, and the open web was available in the way the gym in your building is available. It was called a "walled garden". For a few years, AOL effectively was the internet.
Follow that comparison through and the advice writes itself: claim your listing now, before you pay a fortune for the AI equivalent of your domain name. Sensible, as far as it goes. But a ChatGPT profile can't be bought from a registrar; it goes to whoever proves they run the business. So the cost is more likely to arrive as rent than as a ransom. For how rent gets set, Google may be the better guide.
What Actually Launched (Besides Another Dashboard)
The product is Businesses in ChatGPT, in beta, and it runs through a new Business Hub with verification by phone or DNS (three letters guaranteed to send a marketing team in search of whoever "does the website").
The Hub reports mentions, views, clicks and "discovery topics". The US-only Business Agent is a labelled chat, built by OpenAI from the brand's data, that answers shoppers on its behalf.
All of it is free, for now. OpenAI hasn't ruled out charging later. ("For now" is carrying more weight than two words should ever be asked to carry.) With 1.2 billion weekly users, that's quite a lot of "for now".
The Bit That Actually Matters
The real change is quieter. Until now, assistants described your business using whatever they found: scraped pages, a forum thread from 2017 where someone was cross about your returns policy. A verified profile gives a business, for the first time, an official channel to tell ChatGPT what is actually true.
The alternative is guesswork, and guesswork fails in predictable places. One study of AI answers about software brands found 34% of scored outputs contained at least one invented fact, pricing being the biggest category. One sector, but the mechanism travels: when an assistant lacks a reliable number, it supplies a plausible one, with the serene confidence of a sat-nav directing you into a lake. Your Business Hub feed becomes the strongest candidate for the official price, stock and spec.
OpenAI says claiming won't change how often you're recommended, while conceding clearer information might help you surface in more relevant conversations. (Like a gym insisting membership won't make you fitter, though using the equipment might.) Claiming is rational. The question is what it commits you to.
The Ambition: You've Got Mail
The AOL reading is persuasive about direction: the assistant becomes the browser, and your "page" is assembled fresh inside each conversation. Standards like MCP Apps and Google's A2UI are laying the plumbing. Business Agents are the commercial version: your sales conversation, on OpenAI's property, built to OpenAI's spec. Bringing your own agent isn't allowed. (House rules. Their house.)
A brand becomes a kit of parts assembled by someone else. AOL offered brands a place inside its walls too, and brands paid. Ads of the era carried "AOL Keyword" prompts instead of web addresses, which younger readers can think of as a QR code you had to type.
Then broadband arrived and everyone wandered off to the open web. AOL's 2000 merger with Time Warner is now remembered as one of the costliest misjudgements of its era (a competitive category), and the keywords brands had bought went down with the ship.
The Playbook: Google Already Wrote It
If AOL explains what ChatGPT wants to be, Google explains how it will make money. Two precedents fit almost perfectly.
The listing. Google Business Profile started as a free way to fix your details in Maps. Then it became where local search happened, so it stopped being optional. Then ads moved in, around the results you'd claimed for free. Claim it free, depend on it, pay for position.
OpenAI compressed that into a single day: the free Business Agent is the same agent behind its paid ad format. One executive said of organic and sponsored, "the agent that sits behind it should be the same." Google took years to put ads next to the listing. OpenAI attached them at launch, which is efficient, I'll give them that.
Amazon sellers will recognise the shape instantly: the listing is free, the top of the page is not.
The data. From 2011, Google began withholding the search terms behind website visits, and analytics filled up with "(not provided)". The fix was Search Console, which gave partial data back, but only to owners who verified with Google.
ChatGPT's version took weeks. When GPT-6 rolled out on 7–8 October, ChatGPT traffic largely reappeared in analytics as "direct". OpenAI privately confirmed a bug and began a fix on 15 October, though one analysis found most clicks still unlabelled afterwards. Less than four weeks later came a dashboard of mentions and clicks, available only to businesses that verify with OpenAI. Search Console for ChatGPT, essentially.
There's no evidence the sequence was planned, and it would be unfair to suggest it was. I'm simply putting two dates next to each other. Measuring the channel now runs through an account the platform controls.
Side One: The Visibility Industry Meets Its Search Console
The simplest tools go first. An industry built on estimating ChatGPT visibility through sampled prompts now faces free first-party counts, much as rank checkers faced Search Console. Agencies are already threatening to drop tools that prove wildly off.
But the dashboard is thin: no prompts, no conversations, no competitor share of voice. A mention only counts when ChatGPT cites your website, so being named without a link doesn't register, and a click is a click, not a sale. Smaller brands may see very little. And it covers exactly one assistant.
A count can't say whether you appeared for "best running shoes for flat feet" or in a thread of refund complaints. That why is where paid tools earn their keep. Footnote from the Google precedent: Google eventually put its richest data inside its ad products, and OpenAI may sell the missing layer itself.
Side Two: One Landlord, Two Front Doors
OpenAI now runs two front doors into the same room. Organic: ChatGPT recommends you and the user opens your agent. Paid: a sponsored placement leads to the same agent. You supply the content; OpenAI owns the room, keeps the transcript and shares back aggregated themes (a landlord who reads your post and lets you know you received "some letters"). When the shopper is ready to pay, they're handed to your site, so the sale still closes off-platform. For now. There it is again.
Google has gone further, auto-enrolling eligible US Shopify merchants in native checkout inside AI Mode and Gemini unless they opt out (the consent model beloved of gym contracts everywhere). There, the whole sale can happen without the shopper ever loading your site.
Early evidence on the ads isn't encouraging. A working paper under review found paid ChatGPT visits made $0.89 per session for US advertisers, against $2.45 for paid Google Search. One study, so handle with care. Meanwhile, shoppers clicking links inside AI answers have converted substantially better than other visitors this autumn. The recommendation an assistant gives freely appears to be valuable. The one it sells, so far, appears not to be.
Possibly it's timing: an organic referral arrives after the shopper has decided, while an ad interrupts a conversation they believed was neutral. If it isn't timing, brands are paying rent on a room that doesn't sell.
Not One Walled Garden. Four. (Lovely.)
The best argument against AOL is that there's no single garden. Google has checkout in AI Mode and Gemini. Amazon has folded Rufus and Alexa+ into Alexa for Shopping, which takes orders by text message, sponsored products included. Meta launched Muse, an agent that completes purchases with retailers like Walmart, Gap and Best Buy. Amazon has blocked Muse from its site, the corporate version of a "no outside food" sign.
Shoppers aren't picking one either: in one US survey, around 78% of AI shoppers used ChatGPT and 58% Gemini.
So the risk isn't one company swallowing the web. It's every platform trying, and brands feeding four walled gardens at once, each with its own profile, feed, agent and, eventually, toll. Four landlords, one tenant, no break clause.
What This Means for Brands
None of this argues for staying out. Claim the profile, and soon, because verification decides who controls the facts ChatGPT relies on. If resellers, franchise partners, marketplace sellers or a former agency still have access, settle ownership before someone else does.
Treat product data as a channel, with an owner, a review cadence and a target. If your site, Amazon listing and ChatGPT feed show three different prices, the assistant will pick one, and not always the right one.
Use the free counts as a baseline, then judge paid tools on whether they explain movement rather than merely report it.
Invest in what can't be rented back: email lists, communities, your own checkout and, above all, a name customers ask for directly. A shopper who asks for your brand by name is far harder to redirect than one asking for a category.
The Bottom Line
The AOL reading is right that this is a moment to act. It's wrong about the price. You won't pay seven figures for your name. You'll pay every month for your position. Ask any business that has watched its free Google Business Profile slowly fill up with competitors' ads.


WANT TO REACH 70,000+ ECOMMERCE READERS?
Put your brand in front of an engaged audience of 70,000+ subscribers, with 75% based in the US.
Interested in sponsoring our newsletter? Get our media kit & rates.
The Quick Read:
Anthropic launches the roadshow for its IPO, offering 825 million shares and planning to list on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT.
Replit Agent can now buy for your business and help you reach customers, from sourcing supplies to running Google Ads.
AI knows what your brand does, but not who it’s for.
One site opts out of Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode and finds a 0.9% CTR on AI impressions. The surprise: its regular organic clicks drop too.
ChatGPT ads deliver more than six times less value for money than Google Ads, and 82% of advertisers tracked see zero purchases.
The Tools:
🖥️ Raycast - Mac launcher with AI, clipboard history, snippets and extensions.
🌐 Bolt - In-browser AI app builder supporting many frameworks.
📹 Crayo - Auto-generate faceless short-form videos with captions and voiceover.
🗺️ Windsurf - AI powered IDE with an agentic coding assistant.
ABOUT THE WRITER:
Meet Joanna (Jo) Lambadjieva

Jo Lambadjieva is an entrepreneur and AI expert in the e-commerce industry. She is the founder and CEO of Amazing Wave, an agency specializing in AI-driven solutions for e-commerce businesses. With over 13 years of experience in digital marketing, agency work, and e-commerce, Joanna has established herself as a thought leader in integrating AI technologies for business growth.
For Team and Agency AI training book an intro call here.



